Sunday, May 22, 2016

Gay Portrayal

This past quarter, I have been studying how gay people are portrayed in literature. I found some pretty surprising things while reading as well. I found that the two books, Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe and Giovanni's Room, both expressed emotions about being gay that I found fairly relatable. The narrators of each book, Aristotle and David, were also doppelgangers of each other. Their experiences were so similar, except that Aristotle's story was more modern and less extreme because he was a teenager. These books also contained a lot of realistic situations (appropriate for the time periods in which each book was set), which I was surprised to find. In today's pop culture, it is so easy to depict homosexuals as the "flashy and flaming" stereotypes. No characters in these books fit those descriptions. They just weren't stereotypes. I had seen plenty of movies before with gay characters that are often stereotyped and only inserted in the plot for comedic effect. I was surprised that these books took a different take than film. But, considering how film has literary significance, I decided to explore how gay characters are portrayed in film.

I tried looking up some articles but I only found one that was helpful. According to MediaSmarts, gay people were comedic characters in the early years of film, and they were censored out of film and media beginning in the 1930s and the introduction of the Hayes code. When gay characters found their way back into Hollywood, they were portrayed as terrible people or villains. It was not until the 1990s that gay characters developed better reputations (Queer Representation in Film and Television).

I decided to gain some more perspective on gay characters in film to compare them to those in the books I read this quarter. Over the past few weeks, whenever I actually had some downtime (which was not often), I sat down with my laptop and watched a different movie with one or more gay characters every time. The three movies I watched were GBF, Rent, and The Perks of Being a Wallflower. These are modern movies that are all very different in the way gay people are portrayed and it was interesting getting to analyze each film.

First, I watched GBF. I don't know who the intended audience of this movie is, but it sure as hell wasn't me. I felt like the portrayal of the gay characters in this film were way too over-the-top, stereotypical, and unrealistic. They were seen more as objects with their lack of characterization. I was personally offended watching it, even if the film was written by a gay man. The movie made me angry because I felt as if the message of this "comedy" was "all gay guys act like this and you need to keep them around for fashion advice, ladies". This is almost exactly like the early ages of film when gay characters were purely the source of comedy.

Now, Rent. This is a movie I have loved ever since elementary school. Although it is one of my all-time favorite movies, I felt like there was a lack of exposition with the gay characters. There are four gay characters: a black man and his partner the drag queen, and the performer and her partner the lawyer. These characters live in Bohemian New York in the 1980s, so being gay where they live is entirely normal. Although it shows two differing gay relationships, one happy and one unhappy, it does not show much of what living as a gay person is like.

The last movie is my all-time favorite film, The Perks of Being a Wallflower. This one I could relate to the most, being a gay teenager living in a world that is not too fond of homosexuality. Patrick and Brad are both harassed in different ways for being gay, which is a harsh reality that most people are too quick to toss under the rug. Not only that, but they can find themselves in love with people that they cannot necessarily have (straight or not approving). Even though Perks does not focus on Patrick as the lead protagonist, this movie is still the most real of all three.

What exactly is my point? Depending on the film, gay characters are portrayed differently. Sometimes it has to do with spectatorship but other times it has to do with the setting. Either way, film shows a wider variety of gay characters than novels do. Perhaps it is easier for me to identify with a visual representation of homosexuality rather than a written one.

I decided to get more opinions on this. I had Skype calls with two people, a straight male (Josef Allen) and a gay male (Brandon Heath). I conducted interviews with both of them individually over Skype a few days after we met and created audio recordings of our conversation. I asked them all a series of questions, including but not limited to:
  • Have you seen any films that feature gay, trans, or other LGBT characters? If so, what were they?
  • Do you feel that the portrayal of LGBT characters in film is accurate? Are they fleshed out characters or are they depicted as stereotypes for a comedic effect?
  • Do you think it is right to poke fun at LGBT stereotypes in film? If so, is there a limit to how or how much this is done? 
  • Do you believe that LGBT-related films rely on sex as opposed to a more personal romance?
  • Is there a message that films are trying to express by depicting members of the LGBT community? What is it?

I got a lot of fascinating results. They both pretty much agreed that different films portray them differently, and some films portray stereotypes and some do not. However, the most interesting part was why they thought that was.

I specifically wanted to focus on the views that Brandon Heath, 20, had to share. I interviewed him so I could get the opinions from another gay man. His interview was the shortest one because I caught him at a bad time (a challenge I faced with the other two as well). He mentioned that most of the LGBT-related films he had seen were comedies that portrayed gay characters are stereotypes. He goes on to say "Although some stereotypes do hold true in some cases, I don't feel as though these representations are accurate." Because of this, he found himself unable to truly connect with any gay characters. He also mentions how the gay characters were more sex-driven rather than romantically driven. A common myth is that homosexuals, men in particular, have a bigger sex drive than heterosexuals, and that is often played upon in film. Another great point Brandon makes in response to this is "I don't really know if there is a specific message that filmmakers are trying to send about the LGBT community. They don't really think about the community that much while making their movies because they don't actually develop the characters much beyond stereotypes."

In fact, his last point also relates to another person who I reached out to. Below is a brief snippet of my interview with Josef Allen, 17. It is the very beginning of my interview, but it started out with him making a very interesting point. I asked him if it was alright to poke fun at stereotypes of gay people in film and he essentially he said "yes" but only because "that is all that our society knows about homosexuality". He elaborates more in the video below:


Josef continues to talk about how our homophobic society has shaped from the ideas of bigots and religious fanatics. He believes that since we live in a homophobic society, that is reflected in film. Media just continues to "brainwash" people by refusing to delve into the true emotions and struggles that gay people go through. Film just tends to show us the "outer layer", which is the stereotype that ultimately dehumanizes gay people.

Do I personally believe that gay characters are portrayed accurately in film? Not always. Clearly other people are more apt to believe that most gay characters are purely stereotypes. Compared to written literature, it is obvious that film touches on homosexuality in a less heavy tone. Filmmakers are significantly less daring than novelists. Filmmakers are prone to focus more on the visuals than the substance behind them. Novelists are able to dig deep into human emotions and the ideas of human nature and write about them. This is no different in the case of the portrayal of gay people. In conclusion, novelists are able to express homosexuality in words that films can't. Perhaps this is another reason why films focus on the stereotypes. Not only is it because that is all our homophobic society really knows about, but also because they don't know how to accurately visualize who gay people truly are.




WORKS CITED

"Queer Representation in Film and Television." MediaSmarts. MediaSmarts, 2016. Web. 18 May 2016. <http://mediasmarts.ca/digital-media-literacy/media-issues/diversity-media/queer-representation/queer-representation-film-television>.

No comments:

Post a Comment